Sunday, September 27, 2009

means and trigonometric ratios


I recently noticed that two earlier posts contain an identical diagram (surprising how these things slip by). Both instances of the diagram come from old high school textbooks, one dedicated to geometry and the other to algebra. The first occurrence of the diagram was intended to provide an explanation for the names of the  "secant" and "tangent" trig ratios. The diagram occurred again to provide a geometric construction for the arithmetic, geometric, and harmonic means of two lengths.

If we merge the two uses of the diagram, we get some simple identities that relate the means of the lengths to the trig ratios of an angle. Proving them uses only the definitions of the means, the pythagorean theorem and the basic trig ratio definitions.

Consider two lengths, a and b. Assume that $a \leq b$, and construct the segments as shown. PQ is the length a and PR is the length b.

From here, form the circle whose diameter is RQ as shown.With O as the center, construct the tangent to the circle from the point P. Mark the point of tangency as S. The angle POS is marked $\theta$.

Note that the radius of the circle is $r = \frac{b-a}{2}$, and the arithmetic mean am, geometric mean gm, and harmonic mean hm are given by:
\[am = \frac{a+b}{2}\]
\[gm = \sqrt{ab}\]
\[hm = \frac{2}{\frac{1}{a}+\frac{1}{b}}\]
As described briefly in the earlier post, these ratios appear in the construction where the length OP is arithmetic mean, the length PT is the harmonic mean, and the length SP is the geometric mean of a and b.

If you explore the diagram further with the angle $\theta$ in mind, you'll find that $am = r\sec{\theta}$,  $gm = r\tan{\theta}$, and $hm = r\sin{\theta}\tan{\theta}$ (note that the constructed arithmetic mean lies on the secant of the circle, and the constructed geometric mean lies on the tangent). Also, we have
\[\frac{am}{gm}=\frac{gm}{hm} = \csc{\theta}\]
Maybe there is nothing too surprising here, but I like that two important sets of ratios - the trigonometric ratios and the means - are connected by a simple construction.

I found a variaiton on this diagram in A text book of geometrical drawing by William Minifie - it attempts to capture quite a few constructed ratios (including the antiquated versed sine) in a single diagram.



2 comments:

  1. Dan,
    Nice job.. I like the following diagram, which shows The AM, GM, HM and RMS (std dev) mean
    (Yuck, nothing will paste to this box)
    http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Wiki/images/7/75/RMS-AM-GM-HM,gif
    hope I copied that right..

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Pat! I had not seen that one yet. The blogger comments editor is not the best. The comma needs to be a period in the link:

    http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Wiki/images/7/75/RMS-AM-GM-HM.gif

    ReplyDelete